Why Some Leaders Never Raise Major Gifts
By Maurilio Amorim
I’ve sat across from a lot of leaders over the years who will say some version of the same thing:
“I hate asking people for money.”
I understand it. For many pastors, nonprofit leaders, and founders, asking can feel uncomfortable, personal, and even a little exposing. But here’s the truth. If you lead an organization that depends on generosity, fundraising is not a side task. It is leadership.
In many cases, it is one of the main jobs.
That may sound strong, but I mean it. If you cannot bring yourself to ask people to invest in a vision, you should seriously question whether you are in the right role. Because healthy vision requires resources, and resources rarely show up by accident.
Over the years, I’ve had the privilege of helping raise more than $130 million for organizations and initiatives. I’ve learned a lot about approaching donors, investors, and major givers. And while every conversation is different, there are a few basics that great leaders learn to master.
1. Stop thinking of it as asking for money
You are not begging.
You are not cornering someone.
You are not manipulating emotion.
At its best, fundraising is an invitation. You are inviting someone to participate in something meaningful. That mindset shift changes everything. Desperation repels people. Clear conviction attracts them.
2. Be crystal clear about the vision
Most leaders are far too vague.
People do not give significantly to foggy ideas. They give to clear outcomes. They want to know what the opportunity is, why it matters now, and what their gift will actually make possible.
If your case is confusing, your ask will feel awkward. Clarity creates confidence, both for you and for the donor.
3. Listen before you ask
A major donor conversation should never feel like a monologue.
The best asks usually come after thoughtful questions, careful listening, and a real understanding of what the other person values. Donors want to know that you see them as more than a check. They want to know that their values, interests, and priorities matter.
If you do all the talking, you may get through your pitch, but you will miss the person.
4. Make a specific ask
This is where many leaders fall apart.
They dance around the moment. They hint. They soften. They hope the donor will connect the dots.
Don’t.
If the opportunity is worth funding, it is worth asking for directly. A real ask is clear, specific, and tied to the vision. It sounds like leadership, not apology.
And once you make the ask, stop talking.
Some of the most expensive words in fundraising are the ones said after the ask.
5. Remember that stewardship starts before the gift
Great fundraising is not transactional. It is relational.
If someone gives, how you respond matters. If someone says no, how you respond still matters. Trust is built over time. Some of the most significant gifts I’ve seen did not come from one perfect meeting. They came from consistent leadership, credibility, and follow-through.
People invest in visions, yes. But they also invest in leaders they trust.
Here’s the bottom line.
If you lead a nonprofit, church, or mission-driven organization, learning to ask is not optional. You do not have to become slick. You do not have to become someone you are not. But you do have to become comfortable carrying vision into conversations about money.
Because the future of your organization may depend on your willingness to do it well.
And the good news is this. Asking is a skill. Which means it can be learned, practiced, and improved.
The leaders who embrace that tend to discover something surprising.
What they once feared becomes one of the most powerful parts of their leadership.
